Welcome to Brother’s Pizzeria
Brother’s Pizzeria, located in Fresh Meadows, NY, is a traditional pizzeria with a loyal following. With over 40 years of serving delicious pizza, Brother's offers a classic New York experience with huge slices and a cozy atmosphere. Customers rave about the authenticity and quality of the pizza, with many preferring it over other famous pizzerias in the city. The menu is traditional, featuring classics like cheese pizza and chicken rolls that consistently impress. Whether you're a local looking for a nostalgic slice or a visitor wanting a taste of true New York pizza, Brother’s Pizzeria is a must-visit spot.
-
185-04 Horace Harding Expy, Flushing, NY 11365, United States185-04 Horace Harding Expy, Flushing, NY 11365, United States Hotline: +1 718-445-7888
Welcome to Brother’s Pizzeria, a beloved pizza establishment located in Fresh Meadows, NY. Known for its traditional and classic menu, Brother’s Pizzeria offers a wide variety of options, including vegan and vegetarian choices. With amenities such as delivery, takeout, and reservations, this pizzeria caters to a range of preferences and needs.
Customer reviews rave about the authentic New York pizza experience offered at Brother’s Pizzeria. Mark R. praised the friendly atmosphere and generous portions, while Mike L. declared it the best pizzeria in NYC. Crystal P. found it to be a comforting stop after a late-night flight, and Ros Y. reminisced about the nostalgia and consistency of the pizza over the years.
One standout menu item is the Chicken roll, hailed by Rob S. as one of the best he’s ever had. Jimmy C. couldn’t get enough of the Brother Special pie, showcasing the pizzeria’s dedication to quality and flavor. Pam M. shared a heartwarming story of childhood memories tied to the pizzeria and its enduring legacy.
With a focus on traditional recipes and a commitment to excellence, Brother’s Pizzeria continues to be a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic slice, a hearty pie, or a specialty dish, Brother’s Pizzeria promises a satisfying and memorable dining experience.
We were staying in Fresh Meadows and wanted a local Italian place for a light meal. We were greeted by a cast of characters, making us feel at home in an old fashioned authentic pizzeria. The pizzas were huge, so we opted for single slices, which were great. There's nothing fancy here, just fun workers and good food -- which was the New York experience we were looking for. It's an easy walk from the two Marriot properties - you can see it across the highway.
The best pizzeria in NYC hands down. I've been to many this one I keep going back to because it's just so good. I take this over any place in the city like John's of Bleecker or Joe's of Carmine St. This place is bonafide classic pizza with a very traditional menu. If you want to try what NYC pizza was in it's heyday this is the place.
Getting into LGA late at night I looked for some pizza places on the way home and this seemed good. It was okay. I think we just do it better on long island, though queens is technically long island, not about to start all that :P nassau county whatever. It was perfect for us as we headed home right off the parkway.
Thank you, for always being there, Brother's Pizzeria. I always stop in when I'm visiting my parents, and enjoy the nostalgia of the place that's been serving the best pizza in the area for over 40 years. This visit, I sat on the same stool I always did when I was a child, and ordered my usual slice with extra cheese. And it was just as I remembered - crispy bottom, holding up the weight of the extra cheese, nice & hot out of the oven - perfection. I also ordered a pie and some beef patties to bring back to California for my family - a new generation of kids who love Brother's. May they continue to do so for 40 more years.
This place is so underrated. Chicken roll was one of if not the best I've ever had. Pizza was solid and traditional as well. 9/10 regular slice. I like this place a lot, be back for sure.
Another great pizza pie! Their pizza is so good. Better than any other pizza shops I the neighborhood. Just look at this Brother Special pie.
I visited Brother's Pizzeria as I was feeling nostalgic & was visiting nearby. The pizzeria was established by brothers Pete & Joe & we used to get pizza here regularly since I grew up a few blocks away. My dad used to pick up a pie every week & talk to Pete & Joe like they're family. I got a classic slice of cheese pizza & a peach Snapple to wash it down. The pizza was perfect, as I remembered from years ago, thin crust & crispy. The sauce & cheese had perfect flavors. Yum. The Pizzeria is under a new owner of 15 years who told that Pete comes in every Monday for few hours. Unfortunately I'm leaving on Sunday otherwise it would have been great to see him.